DataBreaches.net

DataBreaches.net

The Office of Inadequate Security

Menu
  • Breach Laws
  • About
  • Donate
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Transparency Reports
Menu

In the courts: informed consent and invasion of privacy

Posted on November 30, 2008 by Dissent

Paul Davenport of the Associated Press reports:

An Arizona appeals court panel ruled Friday that the Havasupai Indian tribe can proceed with a lawsuit that claims university researchers misused blood samples taken from tribal members.

Overturning a judge’s 2007 dismissal of the case, a split Arizona Court of Appeals panel said the Havasupai and other plaintiffs had provided enough information to go to trial or at least enough to go forward in trial court pending further proceedings.

The northern Arizona tribe, whose isolated village lies deep in a gorge off the Grand Canyon, claims Arizona State University and University of Arizona researchers misused blood samples taken from more than 200 tribal members for diabetes research in the 1990s by also using it for research into schizophrenia, inbreeding and ancient population migration.

The tribe claims the additional research was conducted without its permission and constituted an invasion of privacy. As a result, the tribe says, some members now fear seeking medical attention.

Howard Fischer of Capitol Media Services focuses on another aspect of the lawsuit, namely that the researchers used the blood samples — allegedly without authorization — to conduct genetic tests that might seriously undermine the tribe’s core religious beliefs about their origin.

Although the latter is not an insignificant claim, I somewhat naturally was drawn to the issue of possible violation of informed consent and the privacy implications. The appellate opinion reversing dismissal of the lawsuit can be found here. If anyone has a copy of the informed consent form tribal members signed, I would be curious to see it.

[headline typo corrected 12-04-08]

Related Posts:

  • Lawsuits over Arizona tribe blood samples settled
  • The Havasupai Indians, Genetic Research and the…
  • More on the Havasupai case and issues
  • Appeals court decision in Hannaford data breach case…
  • New Arizona abortion laws halted

Post navigation

← The doctor will see all of you now
Former UCLA hospital employee pleads guilty →

Sponsored or Paid Posts

This site doesn’t accept sponsored posts and doesn’t respond to requests about them.

Have a News Tip?

Email:

Breaches[at]Protonmail.ch
Tips[at]DataBreaches.net

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

Telegram: @DissentDoe

Browse by News Section

Latest Posts

  • Ransomware attack on indie game maker wiped all player accounts
  • Hospitals in multiple states diverting patients after Ardent Health Services hit with ransomware attack
  • DHS/CISA and UK NCSC Release Joint Guidelines for Secure AI System Development
  • Henry Schein re-encrypted by BlackCat again
  • Europe’s grid is under a cyberattack deluge, industry warns
  • Municipal Water Authority of Aliquippa hacked by Iranian-backed cyber group
  • Ransomware group leaks data allegedly from Granger Medical Clinic
  • IBM, Johnson & Johnson Hit With Second Health Data Breach Suit

Please Donate

If you can, please donate XMR to our Monero wallet because the entities whose breaches we expose are definitely not supporting our work and are generally trying to chill our speech!

Donate- Scan QR Code   Donate!

Social Media

Find me on Infosec.Exchange.

I am also on Telegram @DissentDoe.

RSS

Grab the RSS Feed

Copyright

© 2009 – 2023, DataBreaches.net and DataBreaches LLC. All rights reserved.

HIGH PRAISE, INDEED!

“You translate “Nerd” into understandable “English” — Victor Gevers of GDI Foundation, talking about DataBreaches.net

©2023 DataBreaches.net