Joe Jackson Wins Right To Michael Jackson Medical Records

Joe Jackson has taken one step forward in his quest to file a wrongful death suit following the passing of his superstar son last June.

In papers obtained by the Superior Court of California ruled on Friday that Joe be allowed access to Michael Jackson’s medical records, something that the singer’s Estate had fought against, citing physician-patient privilege.

Read more on The court’s ruling can be found here.

The Estate’s opposition to Joe Jackson’s request for records was not only based on physician-patient privilege, but also on the grounds of privacy and relevance. The court quickly dismissed the privacy claim, holding, as had previous courts, that the right to privacy can only be asserted by the individual whose privacy has allegedly been invaded, and the right to privacy does not extend past death — unlike patient-physician confidentiality, which does extend past death.

So how could Joe Jackson get around doctor-patient confidentiality? His attorneys argued that since Michael was dead on arrival at the hospital, there was no communication and hence, no privilege attaches.

The whole case arises because Joe Jackson claims he was financially dependent on Michael Jackson and wants to sue UCLA for wrongful death so that he can get more money than he is not now getting from the estate as an allowance.

I wonder what would happen if a non-blood relative initiated a similar action. Could courts wind up ordering the release of hospital records to whomever can make a case that they want to sue a physician over a non-relative’s treatment because the deceased had provided them some financial support that they no longer get from the estate because the deceased did not leave them anything in his will?

About the author: Dissent

2 comments to “Joe Jackson Wins Right To Michael Jackson Medical Records”

You can leave a reply or Trackback this post.
  1. Anonymous - February 21, 2010

    he’s his father, i would think he has a right to see his sons records.

    • Anonymous - February 21, 2010

      I can understand why you might think that, Kate, but you’d be wrong. Joe Jackson had no right to see Michael Jackson’s medical records while Michael was alive without Michael’s consent because Michael Jackson was not a minor child. And some protections extend past death. Here’s the relevant part of HIPAA:

Comments are closed.